Tuesday, January 8, 2008

Constitution of Lebanon - English version

Recently, I stumbled upon the English version of the Lebanese Constitution, available on the Lebanon Now website. Since this is such an important document, and out of fear that they might remove it from their site, I have adapted it and put it here below. Many thanks to Lebanon Now.



Preamble


Part A. Fundamental Provisions


Chapter I. On the State and its Territories


Article 1 Territory

Article 2 Territorial Integrity

Article 3 Administrative Areas

Article 4 Republic, Capital

Article 5 Flag

Chapter II. The Rights and Duties of the Citizen

Article 6 Nationality

Article 7 Equality

Article 8 Personal Liberty, nulla poena sine lege

Article 9 Conscience, Belief

Article 10 Education, Confessional Schools

Article 11 Official National Language

Article 12 Public Office

Article 13 Expression, Press, Assembly, Association

Article 14 Home

Article 15 Property


Part B. Powers


Chapter I. General Provisions

Article 16 Legislative Power, One Chamber

Article 17 Executive Power, Council of Ministers

Article 18 Bills

Article 19 Constitutional Council

Article 20 Judicial Power

Article 21 Electoral Rights


Chapter II. The Legislative Power

Article 22 Senate

Article 23 Eligibility to the Senate

Article 24 Electoral Laws

Article 25 Dissolution

Article 26 Location of Government and Parliament

Article 27 Representation

Article 28 No Incompatibility

Article 29 Incompatibility by Law

Article 30 Validating Elections

Article 31 Illegal Sessions

Article 32 Ordinary Sessions

Article 33 Extraordinary Sessions

Article 34 Quorum

Article 35 Publicity

Article 36 Voting Process

Article 37 Vote of No-Confidence

Article 38 Reintroduction of Bills

Article 39 Indemnity

Article 40 Immunity

Article 41 Re-election

Article 42 General Elections

Article 43 Rules of Procedure

Article 44 First Session

Article 45 Presence

Article 46 Parliamentary Order

Article 47 Petitions

Article 48 Remuneration


Chapter III. The Executive Power


Section 1. The President of the Republic

Article 49 Presidential Powers

Article 50 Oath

Article 51 Promulgation of Laws

Article 52 Negotiation of International Treaties

Article 53 List of Additional Presidential Powers

Article 54 Countersignature

Article 55 Dissolution of Parliament by decree

Article 56 Promulgation Time Limits

Article 57 Presidential Veto

Article 58 Urgent Bills

Article 59 Adjourning the Chamber

Article 60 Responsibility

Article 61 Suspension after Impeachment

Article 62 Vacancy

Article 63 Remuneration


Section 2. The Prime Minister

Article 64 Responsibility and Powers


Section 3. The Council of Ministers

Article 65 Powers

Article 66 Ministries, Responsibility

Article 67 Ministers in Parliament

Article 68 Vote of No-Confidence

Article 69 Government Resignation

Article 70 Impeachment

Article 71 Judicial Impeachment Proceedings

Article 72 Consequences of Impeachment


Part C. Procedural Provisions


Chapter I. Election of the President of the Republic

Article 73 Election of the President

Article 74 Vacancy of Presidency

Article 75


Chapter II. Amending the Constitution

Article 76 Proposal

Article 77 Request

Article 78 Priority

Article 79 Majority, Promulgation


Part D. Miscellaneous Provisions


Chapter I. The Supreme Council

Article 80 Function, Composition, Organizational Law


Chapter II. Finances

Article 81 Integral Tax Law

Article 82 Rule of Law

Article 83 Yearly Budget

Article 84 Budget Discussion

Article 85 Extraordinary Credit

Article 86 Provisional Budget

Article 87 Final Financial Accounts, Auditing Bureau

Article 88 Public Loan

Article 89 Contracts, Concessions, Resources and Monopolies


Part E. Provisions Relating to the Mandatory Power and the League of Nations

Article 90 ...

Article 91 ...

Article 92 ...

Article 93 ...

Article 94 ...


Part F. On the Abolition of Political Confessionalism

Article 95 National Committee


Part G. Provisions Relating to the Election and Functions of the Senate

Article 96 ...

Article 97 ...

Article 98 ...

Article 99 ...

Article 100 ...


Part H. Additional Provisions

Article 101 Greater Lebanon, The Lebanese Republic

Article 102 Abrogation of Old Laws


Preamble

a. Lebanon is a sovereign, free, and independent country. It is a final homeland for all its citizens. It is unified in its territory, people, and institutions within the boundaries defined in this constitution and recognized internationally.

b. Lebanon is Arab in its identity and in its association. It is a founding and active member of the League of Arab States and abides by its pacts and covenants. Lebanon is also a founding and active member of the United Nations Organization and abides by its covenants and by the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. The Government shall embody these principles in all fields and areas without exception.

c. Lebanon is a parliamentary democratic republic based on respect for public liberties, especially the freedom of opinion and belief, and respect for social justice and equality of rights and duties among all citizens without discrimination.

d. The people are the source of authority and sovereignty; they shall exercise these powers through the constitutional institutions.

e. The political system is established on the principle of separation, balance, and cooperation amongst the various branches of Government.

f. The economic system is free and ensures private initiative and the right to private property.

g. The even development among regions on the educational, social, and economic levels shall be a basic pillar of the unity of the state and the stability of the system.

h. The abolition of political confessionalism is a basic national goal and shall be achieved according to a gradual plan.

i. Lebanese territory is one for all Lebanese. Every Lebanese has the right to live in any part of it and to enjoy the sovereignty of law wherever he resides. There is no segregation of the people on the basis of any type of belonging, and no fragmentation, partition, or colonization.

j. There is no constitutional legitimacy for any authority which contradicts the 'pact of communal coexistence'. This Constitutional Law shall be published in the Official Gazette.

Part A. Fundamental Provisions

Chapter I. On the State and its Territories

Article 1 Territory

Lebanon is an independent, indivisible, and sovereign state. Its frontiers are those which now bound it:

On the North: From the mouth of al-Kabir River, along a line following the course of this river to its point of junction with Khalid Valley opposite al-Qamar Bridge.

On the East: The summit line separating the Khalid Valley and al-Asi River (Orontes) and passing by the villages of Mu'aysarah, Harbanah, Hayt, Ibish, Faysan to the height of the two villages of Brina and Matraba. This line follows the northern boundary of the Ba`albak District at the northeastern and south eastern directions, thence the eastern boundaries of the districts of Ba`albak, Biqa', Hasbayya, and Rashayya.

On the South: The present southern boundaries of the districts of Sûr (Tyre) and Marji`yun.

On the West: The Mediterranean.

Article 2 Territorial Integrity

No part of the Lebanese territory may be alienated or ceded.

Article 3 Administrative Areas

The boundaries of the administrative areas may not be modified except by law.

Article 4 Republic, Capital

Greater Lebanon is a Republic the capital of which is Beirut.

Article 5 Flag

The Lebanese flag is composed of three horizontal stripes, a white stripe between two red ones. The width of the white stripe is equal to that of both red stripes. In the center of and occupying one third of the white stripe is a green Cedar tree with its top touching the upper red stripe and its base touching the lower red stripe.

Chapter II. The Rights and Duties of the Citizen

Article 6 Nationality

Lebanese nationality and the manner in which it is acquired, retained, and lost is to be determined in accordance with the law.

Article 7 Equality

All Lebanese are equal before the law. They equally enjoy civil and political rights and equally are bound by public obligations and duties without any distinction.

Article 8 Personal Liberty, nulla poena sine lege

Individual liberty is guaranteed and protected by law. No one may be arrested, imprisoned, or kept in custody except according to the provisions of the law. No offense may be established or penalty imposed except by law.

Article 9 Conscience, Belief

There shall be absolute freedom of conscience. The state in rendering homage to the Most High shall respect all religions and creeds and guarantees, under its protection, the free exercise of all religious rites provided that public order is not disturbed. It also guarantees that the personal status and religious interests of the population, to whatever religious sect they belong, is respected.

Article 10 Education, Confessional Schools

Education is free insofar as it is not contrary to public order and morals and does not interfere with the dignity of any of the religions or creeds. There shall be no violation of the right of religious communities to have their own schools provided they follow the general rules issued by the state regulating public instruction.

Article 11 Official National Language

Arabic is the official national language. A law determines the cases in which the French language may be used.

Article 12 Public Office

Every Lebanese has the right to hold public office, no preference being made except on the basis of merit and competence, according to the conditions established by law. A special statute guarantees the rights of state officials in the departments to which they belong.

Article 13 Expression, Press, Assembly, Association

The freedom to express one's opinion orally or in writing, the freedom of the press, the freedom of assembly, and the freedom of association are guaranteed within the limits established by law.

Article 14 Home

The citizen's place of residence is inviolable. No one may enter it except in the circumstances and manners prescribed by law.

Article 15 Property

Rights of ownership are protected by law. No one's property may be expropriated except for reasons of public utility in cases established by law and after fair compensation has been paid beforehand.

Part B. Powers

Chapter I. General Provisions

Article 16 Legislative Power, One Chamber

Legislative power is vested in a single body, the Chamber of Deputies.

Article 17 Executive Power, Council of Ministers

Executive power is entrusted to the Council of Ministers to be exercised it in accordance with the conditions laid down in this constitution.

Article 18 Bills

The Parliament and the Council of Ministers have the right to propose laws. No law shall be promulgated until it has been adopted by the Chamber.

Article 19 Constitutional Council

A Constitutional Council is established to supervise the constitutionality of laws and to arbitrate conflicts that arise from parliamentary and presidential elections. The President, the President of the Parliament, the Prime Minister, along with any ten Members of Parliament, have the right to consult this Council on matters that relate to the constitutionality of laws. The officially recognized heads of religious communities have the right to consult this Council only on laws relating to personal status, the freedom of belief and religious practice, and the freedom of religious education. The rules governing the organization, operation, composition, and modes of appeal of the Council are decided by a special law.

Article 20 Judicial Power

Judicial power is to be exercised by the tribunals of various levels and jurisdictions. It functions within the limits of an order established by the law and offering the necessary guarantees to judges and litigants. The limits and conditions for the protection of the judges are determined by law. The judges are independent in the exercise of their duties. The decisions and judgments of all courts are rendered and executed in the name of the Lebanese People.

Article 21 Electoral Rights

Every Lebanese citizen who has completed his twenty-first year is an elector provided he fulfills the conditions laid down in the electoral law.

Chapter II. The Legislative Power

Article 22 Senate

With the election of the first Parliament on a national, non-confessional basis, a Senate is established in which all the religious communities are represented. Its authority is limited to major national issues.

Article 23 Eligibility to the Senate {abolished 1927}

Article 24 Electoral Laws

The Chamber of Deputies is composed of elected members; their number and the method of their election are determined by the electoral laws in effect. Until such time as the Chamber enacts new electoral laws on a non-confessional basis, the distribution of seats is according to the following principles:

a. Equal representation between Christians and Muslims.

b. Proportional representation among the confessional groups within each religious community.

c. Proportional representation among geographic regions.

Exceptionally, and for one time only, the seats that are currently vacant, as well as the new seats that have been established by law, are to be filled by appointment, all at once, and by a majority of two thirds of the Government of National Unity. This is to establish equality between Christians and Muslims as stipulated in the Document of National Accord The Taif Agreement. The electoral laws will specify the details regarding the implementation of this clause.

Article 25 Dissolution

Should the Chamber of Deputies be dissolved, the decision of dissolution must provide for the holding of new elections in accordance with Article 24 and within a period not exceeding three months.

Article 26 Location of Government and Parliament

The Government and the Chamber of Deputies shall be located in Beirut.

Article 27 Representation

A member of the Chamber represents the whole nation. No restriction or stipulation may be imposed upon his mandate by his electors.

Article 28 No Incompatibility

A Deputy may also occupy a ministerial position. Ministers, all or in part, may be selected from among the members of the Chamber or from persons outside the Chamber.

Article 29 Incompatibility by Law

Cases in which persons are disqualified from becoming Deputies are determined by law.

Article 30 Validating Elections

The Deputies alone have competence to judge the validity of their mandate. No Deputy's mandate may be invalidated except by a majority of two thirds of the votes of the entire membership. This clause is automatically cancelled as soon as the Constitutional Council is established and as soon as the laws relating to it are implemented.

Article 31 Illegal Sessions

Meetings of the Chamber outside those set for legal sessions are unlawful and ipso facto null and void.

Article 32 Ordinary Sessions

The Chamber meets each year in two ordinary sessions. The first session opens on the first Tuesday following 15 March and continues until the end of May. The second session begins on the first Tuesday following 15 Oct; its meetings are reserved for the discussion of and voting on the budget before any other work. This session lasts until the end of the year.

Article 33 Extraordinary Sessions

The ordinary sessions begin and end automatically on the dates fixed in Article 32. The President of the Republic in consultation with the Prime Minister may summon the Chamber to extraordinary sessions by a decree specifying the dates of the opening and closing of the extraordinary sessions as well as the agenda. The President of the Republic is required to convoke the Chamber if an absolute majority of the total membership so requests.

Article 34 Quorum

The Chamber is not validly constituted unless the majority of the total membership is present. Decisions are to be taken by a majority vote. Should the votes be equal, the question under consideration is deemed rejected.

Article 35 Publicity

The meetings of the Chamber are public. However, at the request of the Government or of five Deputies, the Chamber may sit in secret sessions. It may then decide whether to resume the discussion of the same question in public.

Article 36 Voting Process

Votes are to be cast verbally or by the members standing, except for elections when the ballot is secret. With respect to laws in general and on questions of confidence, the vote is always taken by roll call and the responses are made in an audible voice.

Article 37 Vote of No-Confidence

Every Deputy has the absolute right to raise the question of no-confidence in the government during ordinary or extraordinary sessions. Discussion of and voting on such a proposal may not take place until at least five days after submission to the secretariat of the Chamber and its communication to the ministers concerned.

Article 38 Reintroduction of Bills

No bill that has been rejected by the Chamber may be re-introduced during the same session.

Article 39 Indemnity

No member of the Chamber may be prosecuted because of ideas and opinions expressed during the period of his mandate.

Article 40 Immunity

No member of the Chamber may, during the sessions, be prosecuted or arrested for a criminal offense without the permission of the Chamber, except when he is caught in the act.

Article 41 Re-election

Should a seat in the Chamber become vacant, the election of a successor begins within two months. The mandate of the new member does not exceed that of the old member whose place he is taking; however, should the seat in the Chamber become vacant during the last six months of its mandate, no successor may be elected.

Article 42 General Elections

General elections for the renewal of the Chamber shall take place within a sixty day period preceding the expiration of its mandate.

Article 43 Rules of Procedure

The Chamber draws up its own internal rules and procedures.

Article 44 First Session

Each time a new Chamber is elected, the Chamber meets under the presidency of the oldest member and the secretariat or the two youngest. It will then elect separately, by a secret ballot and by an absolute majority of the votes cast, the President and the Vice President of the Chamber to hold office for the length or the Chamber's term. At the third ballot, a relative majority is sufficient. Should the votes be equal, the oldest candidate is considered elected.

Every time a new Chamber or Deputies is elected, as well as in the October session or each year, the Chamber elects two Secretaries by secret ballot according to the majority stipulated in the first part or this article.

The Chamber may, once only, two years after the election or its President and his Deputy, and in the first session it holds, withdraw its confidence from the President of the Chamber or his Deputy by a decision of two thirds of the Chamber, based on a petition signed by at least ten Deputies. The Chamber, at such point, must hold an immediate session to fill the vacant post.

Article 45 Presence

Members of the Chamber may only vote when they are present at the meeting. Voting by proxy shall not be permitted.

Article 46 Parliamentary Order

The Chamber has the exclusive right to maintain order in its meetings through its President.

Article 47 Petitions

Petitions to the Chamber may not be presented except in writing. They may not be presented verbally or at the bar of the Chamber.

Article 48 Remuneration

The remuneration of members of the Chamber is determined by law.

Chapter III. The Executive Power

Section 1. The President of the Republic

Article 49 Presidential Powers

The President of the Republic is the bead of the state and the symbol of the nation's unity. He shall safeguard the constitution and Lebanon's independence, unity, and territorial integrity. The President shall preside over the Supreme Defense Council and be the Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces which fall under the authority of the Council of Ministers.

The President of the Republic shall be elected by secret ballot and by a two thirds majority of the Chamber of Deputies. After a first ballot, an absolute majority shall be sufficient. The President's term is for six years. He may not be re-elected until six years after the expiration of his last mandate. No one may be elected to the Presidency of the Republic unless he fulfills the conditions of eligibility for the Chamber of Deputies.

It is also not possible to elect judges, Grade One civil servants, or their equivalents in all public institutions to the Presidency during their term or office or within two years following the date of their resignation or their leaving office for whatever reason.

Article 50 Oath

Upon assuming office, the President of the Republic shall take an oath of fidelity before the Parliament to the Lebanese nation and the constitution in the following terms:

"I swear by Almighty God to observe the Constitution and the laws of the Lebanese nation and to maintain the independence of Lebanon and its territorial integrity."

Article 51 Promulgation of Laws

The President of the Republic promulgates the laws after they have been approved by the Chamber in accordance with the time limits specified by the constitution. He asks for the publication or these laws, and he may not modify these laws or exempt anyone from complying with their provisions.

Article 52 Negotiation of International Treaties

The President of the Republic negotiates international treaties in coordination with the Prime Minister. These treaties are not considered ratified except after agreement of the Council of Ministers. They are to be made known to the Chamber whenever the national interest and security of the state permit. However, treaties involving the finances of the state, commercial treaties and in general treaties that cannot be renounced every year are not considered ratified until they have been approved by the Chamber.

Article 53 List of Additional Presidential Powers

The President presides over the Council of Ministers when he wishes without participating in voting.

The President designates the Prime Minister in consultation with the President of the Chamber of Deputies based on parliamentary consultations which are binding and the content of which the President formally discloses to the Prime Minister.

The President alone issues the decree which designates the Prime Minister.

He issues, in agreement with the Prime Minister, the decree appointing the Cabinet and the decrees accepting the resignation of Ministers.

He issues, on his own authority, the decrees accepting the resignation of the Cabinet or considering it resigned.

He forwards to the Chamber of Deputies Bills that are delivered to him by the Council of Ministers.

He accredits ambassadors and accepts the credentials of ambassadors.

He presides over official functions and grants official decorations by decree.

He grants particular pardons by decree, but a general amnesty cannot be granted except by a law.

He addresses, when necessary, letters to the Chamber of Deputies.

He may introduce, from outside the agenda, any urgent matter to the council of Ministers.

He may, in agreement with the Prime Minister, call the Council of Ministers to an extraordinary session, whenever he deems this necessary.

Article 54 Countersignature

The decisions of the President must be countersigned by the Prime Minister and the Minister or Ministers concerned except the decree designating a new Prime Minister and the decree accepting the resignation of the Cabinet or considering it resigned. Decrees issuing laws must be countersigned by the Prime Minister.

Article 55 Dissolution of Parliament by decree

The President of the Republic may, in accordance with the conditions stipulated in Articles 65 and 77 of this constitution, ask the Council of Ministers to dissolve the Chamber of Deputies before the expiration of its mandate. If the Council, based on this request, decides to dissolve the Chamber of Deputies, the President issues the decree dissolving it, and in this case, the electoral bodies meets as provided for in Article 25, and the new Chamber is to be called to convene within fifteen days after the proclamation of the election.

The administrative staff of the Chamber of Deputies continues to function until the election or a new Chamber.

If elections are not held within the time limit specified in Article 25 of the constitution, the decree dissolving the Chamber is considered null and void, and the Chamber of Deputies continues to exercise its powers according to the stipulations of the constitution.

Article 56 Promulgation Time Limits

The President of the Republic promulgates the laws which have been adopted within one month of their transmission to the Government. He must promulgate laws that were declared urgent by a special decision of the Chamber within five days.

The President issues decrees and requests their promulgation; he has the right to ask the Council of Ministers to review any decision that the Chamber has taken within fifteen days of the decision's transmission to the Presidency. If the Council of Ministers insists on the decision or if the time limit passes without the decree being issued or returned, the decision or decree is considered legally operative and must be promulgated.

Article 57 Presidential Veto

The President of the Republic, after consultation with the Council of Ministers, has the right to request the reconsideration of a law once during the period prescribed for its promulgation. This request may not be refused. When the President exercises this right, he is not required to promulgate this law until it has been reconsidered and approved by an absolute majority of all the members legally composing the Chamber. If the time limits pass without the law being issued or returned, the law is considered legally operative and must be promulgated.

Article 58 Urgent Bills

Every Bill the Council of Ministers deems urgent and in which this urgency is indicated in the decree of transmission to the Chamber of Deputies may be issued by the President within forty days following its communication to the Chamber, after including it on the agenda of a general meeting, reading it aloud before the Chamber, and after the expiration of the time limit without the Chamber acting on it.

Article 59 Adjourning the Chamber

The President of the Republic may adjourn the Chamber for a period not exceeding one month, but he may not do so twice during the same session.

Article 60 Responsibility

While performing his functions, the President of the Republic may not be held responsible except when he violates the constitution or in the case of high treason.

However, his responsibility in respect of ordinary crimes is subject to the ordinary laws. For such crimes, as well as for violation of the constitution and for high treason, he may not be impeached except by a majority of two thirds of the total membership of the Chamber of Deputies. He is to be tried by the Supreme Council provided for in Article 80. The functions of Public Prosecutor of the Supreme Council are performed by a judge appointed by the Supreme Council in plenary session.

Article 61 Suspension after Impeachment

Should the President of the Republic be impeached, he is suspended from his functions. The presidency remains vacant until the Supreme Council has settled the matter.

Article 62 Vacancy

Should the Presidency become vacant for any reason whatsoever, the Council of Ministers exercises the powers of the President by delegation.

Article 63 Remuneration

The remuneration of the President of the Republic is determined by a law. It may not be increased or reduced during his term of office.

Section 2. The Prime Minister

Article 64 Responsibility and Powers

The Prime Minister is the Head of Government and its representative. He speaks in its name and is responsible for executing the general policy that is set by the Council of Ministers. He exercises the following powers:

1. He heads the Council of Ministers and is ex officio Deputy Head of the Supreme Defense Council.

2. He conducts the parliamentary consultations involved in forming a Cabinet. He signs, with the President, the decree forming the Cabinet. The Cabinet must present its general statement or policy to the Chamber and gain its confidence within thirty days of the date of issuance of the decree in which the Cabinet was formed. The Cabinet does not exercise its powers before it gains the Chamber's confidence nor after it has resigned or is considered resigned, except in the narrow sense of managing affairs.

3. He presents the Government's general policy statements before the Chamber of Deputies.

4. He signs, along with the President, all decrees, except the decree which designates him the head of the Government, and the decree accepting the Cabinet's resignation or considering it resigned.

5. He signs the decree calling for an extraordinary parliamentary session, decrees issuing laws, and requests for reviewing laws.

6. He calls the Council of Ministers into session and sets its agenda, and he informs the President and the Ministers beforehand of the subjects included on the agenda and of the urgent subjects that will be discussed.

7. He supervises the activities of the public administrations and institutions, coordinates among the Ministers and provides general guidance to ensure the proper progress of affairs.

8. He holds working meetings with the competent authorities in the Government in the presence of the concerned Minister.

Section 3. The Council of Ministers

Article 65 Powers

Executive authority is vested in the Council of Ministers. It is the authority to which the armed forces are subject. Among the powers that it exercises are the following:

1. It sets the general policy of the Government in all fields, prepares Bills and organizational decrees and makes the decisions necessary for implementing them.

2. It watches over the execution of laws and regulations and supervises the activities of all the Government's branches including the civil, military, and security administrations and institutions without exception.

3. It appoints Government employees and dismisses them and accepts their resignations according to the law.

4. It dissolves the Chamber of Deputies upon the request of the President of the Republic if the Chamber of Deputies, for no compelling reasons, fails to meet during one of its regular periods and fails to meet throughout two successive extraordinary periods, each longer than one month, or if the Chamber returns an annual budget plan with the aim or paralyzing the Government. This right cannot be exercised a second time if it is for the same reasons which led to the dissolution of the Chamber the first time.

5. The Council of Ministers meets in a locale specifically set aside for it, and the President chairs its meetings when he attends. The legal quorum for a Council meeting is a majority of two thirds of its members. It makes its decisions by consensus. If that is not possible, it makes its decisions by vote of the majority of attending members. Basic national issues require the approval of two thirds of the members of the Council named in the decree forming the Cabinet. Basic national issues are considered the following:

The amendment of the constitution, the declaration of a state of emergency and its termination, war and peace, general mobilization, international agreements and treaties, the annual government budget, comprehensive and long-term development projects, the appointment of Grade One government employees and their equivalents, the review of the administrative map, the dissolution of the Chamber of Deputies, electoral laws, nationality laws, personal status laws, and the dismissal of Ministers.

Article 66 Ministries, Responsibility

Only Lebanese who satisfy the conditions for becoming deputies may assume ministerial posts. The Ministers administer the Government's services and assume the responsibility of applying the laws and regulations, each one according to the affairs of his administration and what is specific to them. Ministers are collectively responsible before the Chamber for the general policy of the Government and individually responsible for their personal actions.

Article 67 Ministers in Parliament

Ministers may attend the Chamber if they so desire and they have the right to be heard whenever they request to speak. They may be assisted by whomever they select from among the officials of their Departments.

Article 68 Vote of No-Confidence

When the Chamber, in accordance with Article 37, passes a vote of no-confidence in a Minister, that Minister is required to resign.

Article 69 Government Resignation

The Government is considered resigned in the following circumstances:

a. if the Prime Minister resigns;

b. if it loses more than a third of the members specified in the decree forming it;

c. if the Prime Minister dies;

d. at the beginning of the term of the President of the Republic;

e. at the beginning of the term of the Chamber of Deputies;

f. when it loses the confidence of the Chamber of Deputies based on the Chamber's initiative or based on the Council's initiative to gain the Chamber's confidence.

Ministers are to be dismissed by a decree signed by the President and the Prime Minister in accordance with Article 65 of the constitution.

When the Council resigns or is considered resigned, the Chamber of Deputies is automatically considered in extraordinary session until a new Council has been formed and has gained the Chamber's confidence.

Article 70 Impeachment

The Chamber of Deputies has the right to impeach the Prime Minister and Ministers for high treason or for serious neglect of their duties. The decision to impeach may not be taken except by a majority of two thirds of the total membership of the Chamber.

A special law is to be issued to determine the conditions of the civil responsibility of the Prime Minister and individual Ministers.

Article 71 Judicial Impeachment Proceedings

The impeached Prime Minister or Minister is tried by the Supreme Council.

Article 72 Consequences of Impeachment

A Prime Minister or Minister leaves office as soon as the decision of impeachment concerning him is issued. If he resigns, his resignation does not prevent judicial proceedings from being instituted or continued against him.

Part C. Procedural Provisions

Chapter I. Election of the President of the Republic

Article 73 Election of the President

One month at least and two months at most before the expiration of the term of office of the President of the Republic, the Chamber is summoned by its President to elect the new President of the Republic. However, should it not be summoned for this purpose, the Chamber meets of its own accord on the tenth day preceding the expiration of the President's term of office.

Article 74 Vacancy of Presidency

Should the Presidency become vacant through the death or resignation of the President or for any other cause, the Chamber meets immediately and by virtue of the law to elect a successor. If the Chamber happens to be dissolved at the time the vacancy occurs, the electoral bodies are convened without delay and, as soon as the elections have taken place, the Chamber meets by virtue of the law.

Article 75

The Chamber meeting to elect the President of the Republic is considered an electoral body and not a legislative assembly. It must proceed immediately, without discussion or any other act, to elect the Head of the State.

Chapter II. Amending the Constitution

Article 76 Proposal

The constitution may be revised upon the proposal of the President of the Republic. In such a case the Government submits a draft law to the Chamber of Deputies.

Article 77 Request

The constitution may also be revised upon the request of the Chamber of Deputies. In this case the following procedures are to be observed:

During an ordinary session and at the request of at least ten of its members, the Chamber of Deputies may recommend, by a majority of two thirds of the total members lawfully composing the Chamber, the revision of the constitution.

However, the articles and the questions referred to in the recommendation must be clearly defined and specified. The President of the Chamber then transmits the recommendation to the Government requesting it to prepare a draft law relating thereto. If the Government approves the recommendation of the Chamber by a majority of two thirds, it must prepare the draft amendment and submit it to the Chamber within four months; it does not agree, it shall return the decision to the Chamber for reconsideration. If the Chamber insists upon the necessity of the amendment by a majority of three fourths of the total members lawfully composing the Chamber, the President of the Republic has then either to accede to the Chamber's recommendation or to ask the Council of Ministers to dissolve the Chamber and to hold new elections within three months. If the new Chamber insists on the necessity of amending the constitution, the Government must yield and submit the draft amendment within four months.

Article 78 Priority

When a draft law dealing with a constitutional amendment is submitted to the Chamber, it must confine itself to its discussion before any other work until a final vote is taken. It may discuss and vote only on articles and questions clearly enumerated and defined in the draft submitted to it.

Article 79 Majority, Promulgation

When a draft law dealing with a constitutional amendment is submitted to the Chamber, it cannot discuss it or vote upon it except when a majority of two thirds of the members lawfully composing the Chamber are present. Voting is by the same majority.

The President of the Republic is required to promulgate the law of the constitutional amendment under the same conditions and in the same form as ordinary laws. He has the right, within the period established for the promulgation, to ask the Chamber to reconsider the draft, after consultation with the council of Ministers, in which case the vote is by a majority of two thirds.

Part D. Miscellaneous Provisions

Chapter I. The Supreme Council

Article 80 Function, Composition, Organizational Law

The Supreme Council, whose function is to try Presidents and Ministers, consists of seven deputies elected by the Chamber of Deputies and of eight of the highest Lebanese judges, according to their rank in the judicial hierarchy, or, in case of equal ranks, in the order of seniority. They meet under the presidency of the judge of the highest rank. The decisions of condemnation by the Supreme Council are rendered by a majority of ten votes. A special law is to be issued to determine the procedure to be followed by this Council.

Chapter II. Finances

Article 81 Integral Tax Law

No public taxes may be imposed and no new taxes established or collected in the Lebanese Republic except by a comprehensive law which applies to the entire Lebanese territory without exception.

Article 82 Rule of Law

No tax may be modified or abolished except by virtue of law.

Article 83 Yearly Budget

Each year at the beginning of the October session, the Government has to submit to the Chamber of Deputies the general budget estimates of state expenditures and revenues for the following year. The budget is voted upon article by article.

Article 84 Budget Discussion

During the discussion of the budget and draft laws involving the opening of supplementary or extraordinary credits, the Chamber may not increase the credits proposed in the budget or in the draft laws mentioned above either by way of amendment or by means of a proposal. The Chamber may, however, adopt, by way of proposal, laws involving further expenditures after the close of this discussion.

Article 85 Extraordinary Credit

No extraordinary credit may be opened except by a special law. Nevertheless, should unforeseen circumstances render urgent expenditures necessary, the President of the Republic may issue a decree, based on a decision of the Council or Ministers, to open extraordinary or supplementary credits or transfer appropriations in the budget as long as these credits do not exceed a maximum limit specified in the budget law. These measures are to be submitted to the Chamber for approval at the first ensuing session.

Article 86 Provisional Budget

If the Chamber of Deputies has not given a final decision on the budget estimates before the expiration of the session devoted to the examination of the budget, the President of the Republic, in coordination with the Prime Minister, immediately convenes the Chamber for an extraordinary session which lasts until the end of January in order to continue the discussion of the budget; if, at the end of this extraordinary session, the budget estimates have not been finally settled, the Council of Ministers may take a decision on the basis of which a decree is issued by the President giving effect to the above estimates in the form in which they were submitted to the Chamber. However, the Council of Ministers may not exercise this right unless the budget estimates were submitted to the Chamber at least fifteen days before the commencement of its session. Nevertheless, during the said extraordinary session, taxes, charges, duties, imposts, and other kinds of revenues continue to be collected as before. The budget of the previous year is adopted as a basis. To this must be added the permanent credits which have been dropped, and the Government fixes the expenditures for the month of January on the basis of the 'provisional twelfth.'

Article 87 Final Financial Accounts, Auditing Bureau

The final financial accounts of the administration for each year must be submitted to the Chamber for approval before the promulgation of the budget of the year following. A special law is to be issued for the setting up of an Auditing Bureau.

Article 88 Public Loan

No public loan or undertaking involving an expenditure from the treasury funds may be contracted except by virtue of a law.

Article 89 Contracts, Concessions, Resources, and Monopolies

No contract or concession for the exploitation of the natural resources of the country, or a public utility service, or a monopoly may be granted except by virtue of a law and for a limited period.

Part E. Provisions Relating to the Mandatory Power and the League of Nations

Article 90 Abolished in 1943

Article 91 Abolished in 1943

Article 92 Abolished in 1943

Article 93 Abolished in 1947

Article 94 Abolished in 1943

Part F. On the Abolition of Political Confessionalism

Article 95 National Committee

The first Chamber or Deputies which is elected on the basis of equality between Muslims and Christians takes the appropriate measures to realize the abolition of political confessionalism according to a transitional plan. A National Committee is to be formed, headed by the President of the Republic, including, in addition to the President of the Chamber of Deputies and the Prime Minister, leading political, intellectual, and social figures.

The tasks of this Committee are to study and propose the means to ensure the abolition of confessionalism, propose them to the Chamber of Deputies and the Ministers, and supervise the execution of the transitional plan.

During the transitional phase:

a. The confessional groups are to be represented in a just and equitable fashion in the formation of the Cabinet.

b. The principle of confessional representation in public service jobs, in the judiciary, in the military and security institutions, and in public and mixed agencies are to be cancelled in accordance with the requirements of national reconciliation; they shall be replaced by the principle of expertise and competence. However, Grade One posts and their equivalents are exempt from this rule, and the posts must be distributed equally between Christians and Muslims without reserving any particular job for any confessional group but rather applying the principles of expertise and competence.

Part G. Provisions Relating to the Election and Functions of the Senate

Article 96 Abolished in 1947

Article 97 Abolished in 1947

Article 98 Abolished in 1947

Article 99 Abolished in 1947

Article 100 Abolished in 1947

Part H. Additional Provisions

Article 101 Greater Lebanon, The Lebanese Republic

Beginning 1 Sep 1929, the state of 'Greater Lebanon' is to be known as 'The Lebanese Republic' without any other change or modification.

Article 102 Abrogation of Old Laws

All legislative provisions contrary to the present constitution are abrogated.

Rockets fired from Lebanon on Israel

Is this Iran hitting back for the incident yesterday between their ships and the US Navy?

From CNN:
Two Katyusha rockets were fired into northern Israel from Lebanon on Monday night, an Israeli police spokesman said.

It's the first time in more than six months that such a rocket has been fired from Lebanon into Israel.

Israeli munitions experts have examined the rockets, which landed in the northern city of Shlomi, police spokesman Micky Rosenfeld said.

One rocket landed on a house patio and the other near a road, but there were no immediate reports of damage or injuries.

Katyusha rockets have a range of up to 25 km (15 miles) -- much longer than the more crude Qassam rockets, which are more commonly fired from Gaza into Israel.

A spokesman for militant group Hezbollah said he could not confirm if his organization was responsible.

Full story can be found here.

Flags, flags, flags

It was only a week ago when riots broke out in the Beirut suburb of Basta because Hezbollah supporters had torn down a flag of Rafiq Hariri. The Lebanese take flags of their leaders quite seriously. Perhaps in response to this incident, the Future Youth Movement has put up a large flag at the entrance road to the American University Hospital of Beirut. Now let’s see how long this flag will last.

Photo 1: Flag of Future Youth Movement at entrance of AUH

The hospital is close to Ain Mreisseh, which is an area that shows that Sunni and Shiite posters can coexist peacefully. In fact, right next to a huge poster of Berri there is a sign directing people to the Hariri Foundation. See pics below.


Photo 2/3: Huge poster of Nabih Berri with sign to Hariri Foundation

The last flag of today is a huge Rafiq Hariri flag located some 100 meters away from the Nabih Berri poster shown above. Last Saturday it seemed as if it was torn down, but when I came back the next day to take a picture of yet another vandalized flag (SENSATIONALIST, who, me??), it was already repaired, albeit provisionally. Anyway, most likely the wind had blown it off.

Photo 4: Flag of Hariri, vandalized or torn by the wind?

What’s most important to notice in this time of increasing polarization is that these two huge flags of Berri and Hariri have been there hanging peacefully almost next to each other since quite some time already. Somehow, that’s hopeful.

Monday, January 7, 2008

A solution reached in Lebanon?

News came through that the Arab League, for once in its life, has reached what seems to be a workable solution regarding the Lebanese situation. The League proposes Michel Suleiman to be the new president who then has to form a unity government, based upon a 10-10-10 distribution of seats: 10 for March 8, 10 for March 14 and, unique, 10 seats for the president, with no party having veto rights.

Also, the president will stay on for only 2 years with the primary assignment to arrange for a new election law. Clearly, this is a gesture to Michel Aoun who can now be appeased by the promise of running for office next time around.

This solution will give the president much more power and basically overthrows the Taif Agreement, something that March 8 was considering recently, while March 14 has always vehemently opposed any change to Taif. Now, however, March 14 is fully behind the proposal of the Arab League, possibly because they got the candidate it wanted, namely general Michel Suleiman. They must feel confident he is on their side.

That’s a confidence shared by Syria who is also fully behind this proposal. It’s like a poker game where both parties are confident they have a royal flush. Yet, despite all the confidence, no one is really sure what Suleiman will do once he becomes president and where his loyalties lie.

It wouldn’t be surprising that Syria knows more about Suleiman’s political affiliation than March 14 given that Syria has much to lose once the UN Tribunal takes place. Would Syrian leader Assad really pin his political future on the turn of a friendly card?

What's interesting in this regard, was the suggestion of Assad only three days ago that he would be willing to drop a key demand, namely the veto right for the Opposition in return for giving up Suleiman. This might have thrown March 14 off track by making them believe Assad truly does not want Suleiman. By now accepting him, Assad makes it look as if he is making a huge concession.

Still, despite having perhaps doubts about Assad's true intentions, the Sunnis cannot back down after all the strong support for Suleiman. Likewise, the Maronites will be placated by the newly found influence: having 1/3 of the ministerial seats directly placed under presidential control will strengthen the weakened position of the highest job in the country.

The only question will be the reaction of Hezbollah. At first sight, it seems they would lose out under the current proposal: not only didn’t they get a blocking vote in the government, but the Christians are actually getting stronger despite demographic developments that are clearly to the advantage of the Shiites. Were they sold out by Syria due to pressure from other Arab states, including threats to not attend the upcoming meeting in Damascus which would be significant blow to the prestige of the regime?

Unlikely. Syria has been under pressure ever since the Baath party took over. More believable is the scenario that the Syrians are trying to drive a wedge between the Christians and the Sunnis. The alliance between Aoun and Hezbollah can now be played out to the fullest with Aoun claiming that is was his influence that gave the president a much larger role. The initial reaction of Hezbollah to the Arab League proposal was therefore positive.

It will be interesting to see how things will develop: will all sides agree and will Lebanon have a president elected during the next parliamentary session coming Saturday?

Update: LibanCall just reported that Michel Aoun has suggested to distribute the government seats according to the formula 14-11-5, 14 seats being for March 14 and 5 being for the president. This would allow the Opposition to gain the critical one-third of the votes and thus the ability to veto any proposal.

In combination with Nasrallah's insistance on 'true partnership' (read: veto right in unity government for opposition), the prospect of having a new president by Saturday is getting smaller.

New phenomenon in Lebanon: youth gangs

The L’Orient-Le Jour newspaper reported Saturday about a new phenomenon in Lebanon: a youth gang. The article tells the fascinating story behind a violent youth gang that has been terrorizing the posh ski resort of Farayah, in the mountains of Lebanon since summer. They call themselves The Outlaws and the gang has some 20 members who are aged between 15 and 17.

For anybody outside the Arab world, such gangs are nothing new. Violent behavior of youth is, unfortunately, a common event. Take e.g., the Netherlands where the head of the police in The Hague described the New Year’s Eve as ‘quiet’…despite the 128 cars that were set to fire (link in Dutch). Such aggressive and vandalistic behavior is hardly worth mentioning any longer in the western world.

How different the Arab world. Despite the general impression of Arabs as being bloodthirsty, crazy belligerents, it is actually one of the safest places in the world. Lebanon, e.g. is still a place where kids walk home alone at night from parties and where the theft of purses is diligently reported in the local newspapers. Besides the occasional war and the regular assassinations of high-profile targets, it truly is perfectly safe in this country.

Therefore, the news of The Outlaws as being the first youth gang in Lebanon is simply shocking. The article describes how the gang entered the chalet in Farayah of one of their classmates, beat him and his friend up and left them behind for dead. Luckily, the boy and his friend survived and charges were filed.

Given that one of the gang’s members is the son of an ex-minister and the others are also members of good (and above all rich) families, one could expect a cover-up, but the opposite is true. The assault took place on December 20 and already the state prosecutor is handling the case.

What’s interesting is that this gang has been operating since summer 2007, but that no one before has dared filing charges. A previous incident, which only now came to light, dealt with an attack of a boy who was stripped naked, tossed in the back of a car and tied up to one of the crosses on top of a mountain. The parents of the victim settled amicably (read: were paid off handsomely) with the parents of the perpetrators are charges were never filed.

As the author correctly points out, such behavior of parents only enforces kids to misbehave even more. It’s an utter lack of accountability that makes kids realize they can get away with anything. Once, I saw a girl in an expensive four wheel drive hitting another car in the parking lot in Downtown. Without blinking twice, she called her pappy and after listening to him for a bit simply walked away, leaving her driver to work out the insurance details.

Tie another kid naked to a cross, no worries, daddy will make any consequence go away. Parking tickets, traffic accidents, failing tests in school, not getting admitted into the school of choice, teacher wants to suspend you for aggressive behavior?…nothing’s too big a problem to be solved if you happen to have the money for it.

It is exactly this permissive non-accountability that ultimately has lead to the first youth gang ever in Lebanon. No surprise either that it happened in Farayah. It is one of the most up-scale ski resorts in Lebanon and consists mostly of people who visit the place only to ski or pass the summer. It therefore hardly has a village-feel and as a result, lacks social controls. Throw in a bunch of kids left alone by their parents for the weekend, the necessary alcohol and the feeling of being untouchable…the perfect recipe for disaster.

It has an eerie similarity with the raid of Crystal. In both cases, the reason seemed to be young, rich kids believing they can do anything they damn well please. In both cases, also, charges were filed and investigations were launched. Now let’s hope both cases will end with justice being served.

Aoun losing popularity among Christians

When even L'Orient-Le Jour starts making fun of the blind ambition of Michel Aoun, things don't look good. Then again, his call for demonstrations outside the seat of the Patriarch in Bkirki didn't go down too well with many Maronites.

Translation:
Aoun: "I don't see any other chef but me
And I don't see any other president but me
And I don't see any other reference than me
And I don't see anyone, either in front of me or behind me"

with Samir Geagea and Amin Gemayel looking puzzled.
(published on Friday, Jan 4, 2008)

See also here for a relevant article about Aoun's popularity.

Friday, January 4, 2008

Lebanon Update mentioned on LA Times website!

For once a blog entry about me on Lebanon Update: I am mentioned on the website of the LA Times in their article about the raid on Crystal, which you could read about here first! Check it out, it's a fascinating read, obviously!!

OK...back to Lebanon with the news on the death of Jund al Sham leader in Saida this morning and the perhaps matching news of Fatah al-Islam's reappearance, attacking 'disbelievers' on Monday in Saida's refugee camp Ain el-Hilweh.

In my previous post, it became clear we don't need Israel because we have Hezbollah, now we can add that we don't need Hezbollah because we have Sunni extremists causing problems. All we need for total confusion is to wait for evidence that the Hariri family is funding anyone of those groups.

Update: Never mind about that evidence. See here for a story of Bahia Hariri (sister of murdered Rafiq Hariri) funding Jund al Sham, although it seems based upon the widely discredited article by Seymour Hersh. Still, it leaves the impression of reaping what you sow.

“Who needs Israel when you have Hezbollah?”

It is common that children who were abused by their parents will turn into child abusers themselves. On a national scale, the same effect can be observed. E.g., a Dutch movie shown during the European Film Festival in Beirut a month ago claimed that the Jews have become the new Nazis because of the way they treat the Palestinians, a notion that’s well spread in the Arab world. More in general, freedom fighters often become dictators once they grab the power.

It seems that people quite systematically follow bad examples, or rather, learn from their opponents. Just a few observations from the last few days in Lebanon will illustrate this point:

  1. Israel has been occupying part of Lebanon for the longest time. Hezbollah has been occupying downtown for over a year now.
  2. Israel has been blocking the airport and sea ports during the July War. Hezbollah is threatening to do the same in two weeks time.
  3. According to Hezbollah, Israel is behind the targeted killings of anti-Syrian Lebanese politicians/journalists and yet has threatened warned Jumblatt to shut up or else risk being killed.


What to think of this? Is it a sad trait of the human character to imitate one’s enemies? Probably yes, however, one is better off taking comfort in the reassuring predictability of humans. A wary smile, a silent nod are enough to provide the illusion of understanding this stage and its actors; as usual, it doesn’t take much to be content with one’s self.

Still, there are some questions to be answered. Like, why would Hezbollah escalate the conflict? To celebrate the upcoming Ashura, which is always a good moment of Shiite group building? Unlikely. In fact, all is going well for them right now: the government has been paralyzed most effectively and all the tough talk of pushing forward with a simply majority vote for the new president, have proved to be idle poses of toothless politicians. So why rock the boat?

But somehow, most Lebanese are beyond nuances like this. Beaten down by daily stress, they are fed up and have had enough. Under such circumstances, it doesn’t take much to believe the worst and, granted, the news of a deepening of the crisis has been alarming the last two days.

Shooting in the air during New Year’s Eve is immediately explained as evidence that the Lebanese are arming up again; whereas Michel Hayek, Lebanon’s most famous fortune teller, is hardly believed because his predications for 2008 were too positive.

When listening to Walid Jumblatt and sayyed Hassan Nasrallah who gave a TV interview for different Lebanese stations two days ago, one could hear the same negativity, an endless flow of uninspiring pessimism. Coupled with the latest news of Hezbollah threatening to close the airports and sea ports, it is no wonder that you can now hear some Lebanese sigh: “Who needs Israel when you have Hezbollah?”

Thursday, January 3, 2008

Oh my: 50,000,000 USD spent on NYE!!!!

The latest shock wave ripping through Lebanon is the obscene amount of money that was spend during New Year's Eve: 50,000,000 USD. That's 50 Million USD, folks...and in Lebanese pounds, the amount is even higher!!! Feel free to add more exclamation marks and other comments, preferably about waisting money in this time of need, etc. etc. etc.

Just for fun, let's take a closer look at this amount. First, to filter out what was spent exactly on the occasion of New Year's Eve, we would have to determine what is usually spend on any given day in this country. Let's assume the average Lebanese spends 10 USD a day on food. With some 4.5 million Lebanese + visitors, that would already amount to 45 Million USD.

If my assumption is correct (admittedly, it truly is a wild guess), this means that the Lebanese have spent not 50, but 5 Million USD extra on partying.

Let's further assume that out of the 4.5 Million people, one third of those did not do anything special for New Year's Eve because they're babies, elderly, sick and what have you. This leaves us with 3 Million party goers. In turn, that would mean that the remaining party animals have spent a cool1.67 USD per person!

Oops...now that's a boringly low amount!

Nah...it's much more fun to panic:

75,000,000,000 Lebanese Pound spend on New Year's Eve!!!

Wednesday, January 2, 2008

Happy New Year!

Happy New Year to all the readers that have found this blog. Some of you even come here on purpose:-) May the new year bring all what you want!

To keep in style with the mores of Lebanon's politicians whose words you always have to interpret to the best you can, see below for appropriate New Year's Resolutions: